« Does Illinois need clean coal? | Main | Noon rally against the escalation »

Take the green train

The SJR has a story about Amtrak being promoted as an eco-friendly travel option. I like taking it to Chicago whenever I go. I don't have to pay for parking or deal with city traffic. And as much as I like Amtrak, I'm in love with the L. I even wrote a song about the Red Line. Yes, I'm a dork.

The story is a good example of how passenger rail drives economic development. Land values and businesses grow around good public transportation. That means there are some up-sides to the possibility of having a high-speed passenger rail corridor and multi-modal center in the middle of downtown Springfield along the 3rd Street corridor.

Yes, there are problems with installing double tracks along the 3rd St corridor, just as there are problems with consolidation on 10th. Neither option is going to cause the destruction of downtown. It's a little irritating to see the downsides of one option over-hyped while drawbacks to the other are ignored. In some ways, the 3rd Street corridor will help downtown grow.

We'll only see the full economic and environmental benefits if we abandon the idea that public transportation is only for people with no other travel options. The trouble with the proposed multi-modal on 11th is that it's based on twenty year old backward ideas about mass transit.

The proposed 11th Street site is surrounded by important social service agencies. No one has been able to answer whether they plan to: 1) Force service agencies out to make room for the promised economic development, or 2) Ask tourists to walk by two shelters, rehab centers and the county jail near a high crime neighborhood at nighttime if they want to visit Springfield. Those are the only two options and neither one sounds appealing.

The local press finally started covering the full picture so we should be able to have a rational discussion about high-speed rail soon, without all the apocalyptic talk of Springfield's impending doom.

This song has been stuck in my head for the last two days...


TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.willreynolds.us/mt/mt-tb.cgi/1022

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Take the green train:

» Get the freight out! from Where there's a Will, there's a way
The Chicago Sun-Times has an interesting article on high-speed rail and freight traffic delays. But the promise of faster passenger rail is inextricably linked to the down-and-dirty business of freight. To make passenger and commuter trains move faster... [Read More]

Comments

Finally we get a decent article about Amtrak in the SJR and Amtrak gets a chance to show that yes, they can run a railroad. With freight traffic down on the UP, the trains have considerably increased their on-time performance and with stimulus money, they have been able to repair and upgrade cars so that they can respond to demand. From my position next to the tracks, I have seen the Lincoln Service trains go from the standard three cars and business class/lounge car to eight cars today to handle the holiday rush. Now if I could just come up with the money to reopen the lunch/news counter that used to be in the south end of the Amtrak station!

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting. Email address is optional.)